Lot's going on with Apple and DRM. The EU is threatening antitrust action against iTunes, and Apple and EMI announced a new deal on DRM-free music.
Let's think about the EMI deal. EMI, with Apple's partnership, is going to make its library (ex-Beatles!) available on iTunes without DRM, and in close-to-CD audio quality.
The catch? Instead of the usual $.99 per song, EMI's songs will go for $1.29.
What accounts for the higher price? We have a few choices, not mutually exclusive:
1. Songs unencumbered by DRM are worth more, so the price is higher.
2. Songs of higher audio quality are worth more, so the price is higher.
3. Songs without DRM are going to spread more, reducing purchases by other users of the same song, so they have a higher marginal cost and therefore should sell for more.
4. As I pointed out in this post, Apple should be concerned that if iTunes songs are priced below their "stand-alone" profit-maximizing price, then entry by competitors into the portable musice device market is aided. From the perspective of pricing iTunes songs and iPods, Apple should be pricing songs lower than their stand-alone price, but above marginal cost. To eliminate the aid to entry, Apple has incentive to introduce DRM, preventing iTunes songs from playing on other devices.
If Apple drops DRM for some songs, then to maintain a deterrent to entry, it should increase the price of songs.
5. Last argument, it may be that EMI is simply charging a higher royalty to Apple for its songs (why?) and Apple is simply charging the relevantly higher price.
My choice of answers? A combination of all of these. Look at it from EMI and Apple's perspectives. Everything points to a higher price for the DRM-free songs (and by the way, the DRM-encumbered songs are still available at a lower price). "Let's try it and see what happens."
Based on my own recent experience in hitting the 5-machine limit, I would probably opt for the higher priced version. If there were no choice available, I would likely buy almost the same number of songs at $1.29 instead of $.99, when the higher price was for a higher quality and DRm-free version.
A blog on economics, both theory and current events, and world political affairs.
Friday, April 06, 2007
Friday, February 09, 2007
Steve Jobs on DRM
Steve Jobs posted this week on the Apple site a letter in which he argues for the abolition of digital rights management (DRM) software for online music. If DRM were abolished, then any songs purchased from iTunes could be played on any device, and vice versa -- music purchased on any other sites could be played on iPods.
Not too long ago, I wrote a post on why it could be in Apple's interests to prevent iTunes songs from playing on other devices. My basic argument had to do with assumed pricing of songs on iTunes. I argued that Apple was pricing songs above marginal cost, but below the price they would set if they were not also selling iPods. Essentially, Apple was, I argued, trying to prevent new entrants into the portable music player market from getting the benefits of relatively cheap songs from iTunes. New entrants obviously would find entry into the device market easier with a full iTunes library at low prices ($.99).
So what might have changed, in order for Jobs to call for no restrictions on songs purchased on-line?
Three possibilities. One, if Jobs' description of the contracts with the music publishers is correct, then they could shut down the iTunes site within weeks of a determination that Apple's DRM has been hacked. That is a big albatross to have circling over one's head all the time. It is not clear that Apple will be able to stay ahead of the hackers. Jobs may have had to agree to this contract clause when nobody knew whether iTunes would take off, but I suspect he has a bit more negotiating clout at this point.
Two, with more and more online music sellers, we are likely to approach marginal cost pricing of songs. With marginal cost pricing, and more music available, the ability to deter entry into the device market by keeping iTunes songs only for the iPod disappears.
Three, I don't think the incentive to deter entry into the device market is nearly as strong as it was when the iPod was new. Apple has a huge lead, both technologically and in the marketplace, and it is moving on to a whole new competitive arena with the iPhone. The advantages to Apple of having (cheap) songs from other sellers able to be played on its iPods and iPhones outweigh the advantages to Apple of having its songs not be playable on other devices.
I predict that Jobs' recommendation will be accepted.
Not too long ago, I wrote a post on why it could be in Apple's interests to prevent iTunes songs from playing on other devices. My basic argument had to do with assumed pricing of songs on iTunes. I argued that Apple was pricing songs above marginal cost, but below the price they would set if they were not also selling iPods. Essentially, Apple was, I argued, trying to prevent new entrants into the portable music player market from getting the benefits of relatively cheap songs from iTunes. New entrants obviously would find entry into the device market easier with a full iTunes library at low prices ($.99).
So what might have changed, in order for Jobs to call for no restrictions on songs purchased on-line?
Three possibilities. One, if Jobs' description of the contracts with the music publishers is correct, then they could shut down the iTunes site within weeks of a determination that Apple's DRM has been hacked. That is a big albatross to have circling over one's head all the time. It is not clear that Apple will be able to stay ahead of the hackers. Jobs may have had to agree to this contract clause when nobody knew whether iTunes would take off, but I suspect he has a bit more negotiating clout at this point.
Two, with more and more online music sellers, we are likely to approach marginal cost pricing of songs. With marginal cost pricing, and more music available, the ability to deter entry into the device market by keeping iTunes songs only for the iPod disappears.
Three, I don't think the incentive to deter entry into the device market is nearly as strong as it was when the iPod was new. Apple has a huge lead, both technologically and in the marketplace, and it is moving on to a whole new competitive arena with the iPhone. The advantages to Apple of having (cheap) songs from other sellers able to be played on its iPods and iPhones outweigh the advantages to Apple of having its songs not be playable on other devices.
I predict that Jobs' recommendation will be accepted.
The Consensus on Global Warming
A really good blog to keep up on science of climate change that you won't read elsewhere is Roger Pielke's blog.
Roger notes two attempts to remove state climatologists -- David Legates in Delaware and George Taylor in Oregon -- because of their failure to follow the consensus views on global warming. Roger also gives the cite to Heidi Cullen's (of the Weather Channel) post where she speaks about having the American Meteorological Society remove their seal of approval from meteorologists who "can't speak to the fundamental science of climate change" and about the inability of some meteorologists to differentiate between "solid, peer-reviewed science and junk political controversy." Take a look at Roger Pielke's resume and tell me if you see anything other than solid, peer-reviewed science. About all you will see on his site is peer-reviewed science, and it is good stuff.
So what kind of consensus is this, if by speaking out against it you are vilified?
Wait -- another late breaking item, Ellen Goodman from the Boston Globe says
"I would like to say we're at a point where global warming is impossible to deny. Let's just say that global warming deniers are now on a par with Holocaust deniers, though one denies the past and the other denies the present and future."
Now if you read my post on warming from February 1, you will see I agree that global warming (that the average global temperature has increased in the last 100 years) is tough to deny. But that, I don't think, is what Ms. Goodman means when she refers to the deniers of global warming. I suspect that if I said to her that maybe the best response to warming is to make sure that the world economy grows at a good rate for the next 100 years so that our children have the capital and capacity to adapt to climate change, she would consider me a denier. Or if I said that it simply did not make good economic sense to spend a lot on reducing CO2 given the cost of reductions and the relatively minor benefits that would be forthcoming, she would consider me a denier. Or if I said that it was not clear just how much of the warming of the last 100 years was due to anthropogenic greenhouse gas emisssions, she would consider me a denier. Read her editorial and tell me if I am wrong.
At any rate, bringing the Holocaust into the argument over climate change is just going way over the edge.
Roger notes two attempts to remove state climatologists -- David Legates in Delaware and George Taylor in Oregon -- because of their failure to follow the consensus views on global warming. Roger also gives the cite to Heidi Cullen's (of the Weather Channel) post where she speaks about having the American Meteorological Society remove their seal of approval from meteorologists who "can't speak to the fundamental science of climate change" and about the inability of some meteorologists to differentiate between "solid, peer-reviewed science and junk political controversy." Take a look at Roger Pielke's resume and tell me if you see anything other than solid, peer-reviewed science. About all you will see on his site is peer-reviewed science, and it is good stuff.
So what kind of consensus is this, if by speaking out against it you are vilified?
Wait -- another late breaking item, Ellen Goodman from the Boston Globe says
"I would like to say we're at a point where global warming is impossible to deny. Let's just say that global warming deniers are now on a par with Holocaust deniers, though one denies the past and the other denies the present and future."
Now if you read my post on warming from February 1, you will see I agree that global warming (that the average global temperature has increased in the last 100 years) is tough to deny. But that, I don't think, is what Ms. Goodman means when she refers to the deniers of global warming. I suspect that if I said to her that maybe the best response to warming is to make sure that the world economy grows at a good rate for the next 100 years so that our children have the capital and capacity to adapt to climate change, she would consider me a denier. Or if I said that it simply did not make good economic sense to spend a lot on reducing CO2 given the cost of reductions and the relatively minor benefits that would be forthcoming, she would consider me a denier. Or if I said that it was not clear just how much of the warming of the last 100 years was due to anthropogenic greenhouse gas emisssions, she would consider me a denier. Read her editorial and tell me if I am wrong.
At any rate, bringing the Holocaust into the argument over climate change is just going way over the edge.
Thursday, February 01, 2007
The Eiffel Tower is Dark!
The news media is in high gear in anticipation of the IPCC summary for policymakers that will be issued tomorrow. I think I will have to go into hiding for a couple days or my blood pressure will go through the roof. Leave it to the French to darken the Eiffel Tower to reflect the seriousness of the event.
So about 12 years ago, in my Environmental Economics course at Tuck, I had a "skeptic" in to class to discuss climate change -- Robert Balling. Now in the interest of balance, I also invited to the class Donella Meadows (Limits to Growth) and she did attend. It was one of my all time favorite class sessions. The students who were there probably still do not realize how lucky they were to see Balling and Meadows square off -- and agree on much of the science, but not on the policy implications!
So it sounds like one of the news bytes will be that mankind is "very likely" to be a cause of some (how much?) of the warming we have observed. Twelve years ago, Balling, a skeptic, would have agreed to that. I remember him going through the data, with a focus on moderate warming, especially at night and in winters, and more rainfall generally. That, he said is global warming. The question then, and now, is what we should do about it.
So the IPCC summary will try to make a big deal out of the "very likely" language, and all the media will try to use it to say that all skeptics have been discredited. I don't know of any skeptics who deny the theory of climate change (i.e., the causal relationship to CO2) or indeed any who would not agree that some of the warming we have observed in the last 100 years is "very likely" due to human influence.
That is just not the point.
It will be interesting to see the spin if, as I expect, the expected temperature increase and expected sea level increases both fall from previous expected values. How do you spin that into more of a crisis?
So about 12 years ago, in my Environmental Economics course at Tuck, I had a "skeptic" in to class to discuss climate change -- Robert Balling. Now in the interest of balance, I also invited to the class Donella Meadows (Limits to Growth) and she did attend. It was one of my all time favorite class sessions. The students who were there probably still do not realize how lucky they were to see Balling and Meadows square off -- and agree on much of the science, but not on the policy implications!
So it sounds like one of the news bytes will be that mankind is "very likely" to be a cause of some (how much?) of the warming we have observed. Twelve years ago, Balling, a skeptic, would have agreed to that. I remember him going through the data, with a focus on moderate warming, especially at night and in winters, and more rainfall generally. That, he said is global warming. The question then, and now, is what we should do about it.
So the IPCC summary will try to make a big deal out of the "very likely" language, and all the media will try to use it to say that all skeptics have been discredited. I don't know of any skeptics who deny the theory of climate change (i.e., the causal relationship to CO2) or indeed any who would not agree that some of the warming we have observed in the last 100 years is "very likely" due to human influence.
That is just not the point.
It will be interesting to see the spin if, as I expect, the expected temperature increase and expected sea level increases both fall from previous expected values. How do you spin that into more of a crisis?
Tuesday, January 16, 2007
Why is the Islamic Bomb So Slow in Development?
This is probably a naive question. Maybe someone can answer it quickly for me.
The Manhattan Project started in 1942 and in 1945 the United States detonated three nuclear bombs, including an enriched uranium bomb and a plutonium bomb.
Fast forward sixty years: The Iranians have been allegedly working for several years on developing a nuclear bomb but are, by some projections, still years away from being able to produce one (leaving aside the ability to deliver it).
What is going on here?
The Manhattan Project started in 1942 and in 1945 the United States detonated three nuclear bombs, including an enriched uranium bomb and a plutonium bomb.
Fast forward sixty years: The Iranians have been allegedly working for several years on developing a nuclear bomb but are, by some projections, still years away from being able to produce one (leaving aside the ability to deliver it).
What is going on here?
Friday, January 12, 2007
Apple's Effects on Competitors
What a wonderful company Apple is. Who else can you turn to for virtually all of your Christmas presents? From iMacs to Macbooks to iPods, plus all the third-party complementary products, the possibilities for great gifts are unending.
But the topic of the evening is profiting from induced changes in competitors' market values.
S. Jobs announced this past week the new iPhone from Apple (so long as it works on Verizon, I see several such phones in my family's future).
Apple's share price increased by 8.3% on the day. This is pretty amazing, given that the market was expecting a big announcement. Apple clearly surpassed expectations.
But who should suffer from Apple's mobile phone innovation? Two companies that should be hurt by Apple's perceived successful entry into the mobile phone market, in terms of revenues, profitability and value, are Palm and Research in Motion (makers of the Blackberry). Palm fell by 6%. Research in Motion fell by 7.9%.
Now Apple officers trading in Apple shares would clearly violate insider trading laws as the officers of Apple owe a fiduciary duty to Apple shareholders. But that legal argument does not apply to Apple officers, or Apple itself, trading in the shares of Palm or Research in Motion. No fiduciary duty owed there, and mere trading on proprietary information is clearly not illegal. In fact, one could argue that Apple created and owns the information on its innovation, so why can't it trade on it?
Wouldn't it have been a great trade to sell short Palm or Research in Motion, if you knew just what S. Jobs was going to do at MacWorld? And guess what -- for an Apple employee to do such a trade would not be illegal (to the best of my knowledge that is, and I do note that it could violate Apple corporate policy). Perhaps the best idea would have been for Apple's corporate pension fund to have sold short shares in competitors prior to the conference. Not only would Apple make money from the entry into the mobile phone market, but it would also make a fortune from the decline in fortunes of its competitors!
But the topic of the evening is profiting from induced changes in competitors' market values.
S. Jobs announced this past week the new iPhone from Apple (so long as it works on Verizon, I see several such phones in my family's future).
Apple's share price increased by 8.3% on the day. This is pretty amazing, given that the market was expecting a big announcement. Apple clearly surpassed expectations.
But who should suffer from Apple's mobile phone innovation? Two companies that should be hurt by Apple's perceived successful entry into the mobile phone market, in terms of revenues, profitability and value, are Palm and Research in Motion (makers of the Blackberry). Palm fell by 6%. Research in Motion fell by 7.9%.
Now Apple officers trading in Apple shares would clearly violate insider trading laws as the officers of Apple owe a fiduciary duty to Apple shareholders. But that legal argument does not apply to Apple officers, or Apple itself, trading in the shares of Palm or Research in Motion. No fiduciary duty owed there, and mere trading on proprietary information is clearly not illegal. In fact, one could argue that Apple created and owns the information on its innovation, so why can't it trade on it?
Wouldn't it have been a great trade to sell short Palm or Research in Motion, if you knew just what S. Jobs was going to do at MacWorld? And guess what -- for an Apple employee to do such a trade would not be illegal (to the best of my knowledge that is, and I do note that it could violate Apple corporate policy). Perhaps the best idea would have been for Apple's corporate pension fund to have sold short shares in competitors prior to the conference. Not only would Apple make money from the entry into the mobile phone market, but it would also make a fortune from the decline in fortunes of its competitors!
Friday, December 08, 2006
Environmental Dilemmas
More craziness from across the river in Vermont.
So the voters in Norwich approved a bond issue to install a wood-fired boiler for the elementary school. Hanover's new Middle School has one of these, and I imagine that with heating oil prices being so high, the investment's ROI ex post is looking pretty nice. (By the way, I live about half a mile from that boiler and do not notice any ill effects, including no ill effects from the wood chip delivery trucks.)
Norwich voters had one study by a consulting firm available to them when they approved the boiler, and the study said that the emissions from the wood boiler would be nothing to worry about.
Now a new study has been presented (why was this new study done...hmmmm?) showing not only that emissions would be worse, but that the emissions would fall outside of the EPA rules that would be enforced...starting in 2010!!
Even more hilariously, all the EPA regulations are irrelevant in the regulatory sense, since the Norwich furnace is too small to fall under the EPA's regulatory umbrella.
But nonetheless, this new study has put the boiler on hold.
I imagine that in Norwich, VT, more copies per capita of Al Gore's book on climate change have been purchased than anywhere else. Yet here we have an economically sound investment that will reduce net CO2 emissions...and it fails because of the age-old "not in my backyard" argument. Give me a break, please.
Sometime in the future we are going to face some real tradeoffs and we will not be able to say no to everything. Boy, if we can't even put a wood stove in Norwich, how are we ever going to site a nuke in Burlington??
So the voters in Norwich approved a bond issue to install a wood-fired boiler for the elementary school. Hanover's new Middle School has one of these, and I imagine that with heating oil prices being so high, the investment's ROI ex post is looking pretty nice. (By the way, I live about half a mile from that boiler and do not notice any ill effects, including no ill effects from the wood chip delivery trucks.)
Norwich voters had one study by a consulting firm available to them when they approved the boiler, and the study said that the emissions from the wood boiler would be nothing to worry about.
Now a new study has been presented (why was this new study done...hmmmm?) showing not only that emissions would be worse, but that the emissions would fall outside of the EPA rules that would be enforced...starting in 2010!!
Even more hilariously, all the EPA regulations are irrelevant in the regulatory sense, since the Norwich furnace is too small to fall under the EPA's regulatory umbrella.
But nonetheless, this new study has put the boiler on hold.
I imagine that in Norwich, VT, more copies per capita of Al Gore's book on climate change have been purchased than anywhere else. Yet here we have an economically sound investment that will reduce net CO2 emissions...and it fails because of the age-old "not in my backyard" argument. Give me a break, please.
Sometime in the future we are going to face some real tradeoffs and we will not be able to say no to everything. Boy, if we can't even put a wood stove in Norwich, how are we ever going to site a nuke in Burlington??
Friday, November 17, 2006
Unbelievable
It still has not really hit me that we have a socialist in the US Senate. And, even more amazing, he is from the state just across the river from me. Vermont.
It's funny how smoking marijuana affects some people.
It's funny how smoking marijuana affects some people.
An AMT Idea
There has been some more talk about fixing the Alternative Minimum Tax since the Democrats took over Congress (also see my earlier post). Maybe we can actually get some tax reform in the next couple years? That would be a real miracle. The Bush administration’s failure to get Social Security reform and failure to get any tax reform loom large in my evaluation of its overall success.
So here is a free idea for the Democrats. From this point on I start charging.
The issue of revenue neutrality is not being looked at creatively. Discussion has focused on making sure that if some people gain from tax reform, others will have to lose, if we are to maintain revenue neutrality. This ignores the fundamental inefficiency of taxes, which is that they drive a wedge between what one individual earns and what that individual takes home. The wedge causes individuals to forego income-earning possibilities that do not yield enough after-tax income to compensate for the opportunities sacrificed as a result of earning the income (e.g., leisure). If the tax wedge is reduced, then individuals will earn more, yielding more tax revenue, and making themselves better off.
The problem has always been that if you reduce taxes to reduce the wedge, you lose a lot of revenue on income that would have been earned and taxed anyway. This makes tax reduction costly from the point of view of the government’s treasury. The point is very similar to the concept of marginal revenue in the economics of pricing: if a company reduces its price to sell more product, it picks up some additional revenue from the new units sold, but if it has to reduce price on all the units that would have been sold anyway, then total revenue could actually decline.
But the principle remains: tax rate reduction is mutually beneficial, between individuals and the government. In principle, we should be able to strike a bargain that makes both entities better off.
So here is how we might do that. Now all the details of this are not worked out, but I am rather intrigued by the idea.
Right now, I don’t really know if my marginal tax rate for income earned in 2007 is going to be around 42% or around 26%. It will be 42% if I don’t get caught by the AMT and it will be 26% if I do get caught by the AMT. So let me choose at the beginning of the year how I want to be taxed. I will promise the IRS that, so long as my income is at least as high as it was in 2006, then I will pay at least the same amount of taxes that I paid in 2006. But, and this is the kicker, for any additional income that I earn over and above my 2006 income, I will pay only the AMT marginal tax rate, i.e., 26%.
Imagine that I have an opportunity to make an additional $10,000 in 2007. If my marginal rate were 42%, my take-home pay would only be $5800. At that rate, I might choose to spend that time out at my camp instead of earning the income. But if my marginal rate were only 26%, I would forego $7400 by going to camp instead of to work.
So promise me a lower rate on only my incremental income, and I will earn more. The IRS will take in more revenue than it did before, and possibly more than it would have without this tax innovation (I say possibly more since some people would have taken the income earning option even with the higher tax rate).
The point of this scheme is to make tax reform revenue neutral at the level of the individual, not necessarily across individuals. And we define revenue neutrality relative to the prior year’s tax payments.
To make this even more attractive, you could let me “buy down” my marginal tax rate on new income by foregoing some deductions such as mortgage payments. So I would agree to pay 26%, say, on more of my income (I won’t deduct mortgage interest) if you lower the rate of taxation on new income I earn to, say, 24%.
This idea is very similar to health insurance plans that require us to choose at the beginning of the year what kind of plan we want, and how much money we want to put into a reimbursement account. Let’s extend that principle to taxation, remove some inefficiency, and make everyone better off.
So here is a free idea for the Democrats. From this point on I start charging.
The issue of revenue neutrality is not being looked at creatively. Discussion has focused on making sure that if some people gain from tax reform, others will have to lose, if we are to maintain revenue neutrality. This ignores the fundamental inefficiency of taxes, which is that they drive a wedge between what one individual earns and what that individual takes home. The wedge causes individuals to forego income-earning possibilities that do not yield enough after-tax income to compensate for the opportunities sacrificed as a result of earning the income (e.g., leisure). If the tax wedge is reduced, then individuals will earn more, yielding more tax revenue, and making themselves better off.
The problem has always been that if you reduce taxes to reduce the wedge, you lose a lot of revenue on income that would have been earned and taxed anyway. This makes tax reduction costly from the point of view of the government’s treasury. The point is very similar to the concept of marginal revenue in the economics of pricing: if a company reduces its price to sell more product, it picks up some additional revenue from the new units sold, but if it has to reduce price on all the units that would have been sold anyway, then total revenue could actually decline.
But the principle remains: tax rate reduction is mutually beneficial, between individuals and the government. In principle, we should be able to strike a bargain that makes both entities better off.
So here is how we might do that. Now all the details of this are not worked out, but I am rather intrigued by the idea.
Right now, I don’t really know if my marginal tax rate for income earned in 2007 is going to be around 42% or around 26%. It will be 42% if I don’t get caught by the AMT and it will be 26% if I do get caught by the AMT. So let me choose at the beginning of the year how I want to be taxed. I will promise the IRS that, so long as my income is at least as high as it was in 2006, then I will pay at least the same amount of taxes that I paid in 2006. But, and this is the kicker, for any additional income that I earn over and above my 2006 income, I will pay only the AMT marginal tax rate, i.e., 26%.
Imagine that I have an opportunity to make an additional $10,000 in 2007. If my marginal rate were 42%, my take-home pay would only be $5800. At that rate, I might choose to spend that time out at my camp instead of earning the income. But if my marginal rate were only 26%, I would forego $7400 by going to camp instead of to work.
So promise me a lower rate on only my incremental income, and I will earn more. The IRS will take in more revenue than it did before, and possibly more than it would have without this tax innovation (I say possibly more since some people would have taken the income earning option even with the higher tax rate).
The point of this scheme is to make tax reform revenue neutral at the level of the individual, not necessarily across individuals. And we define revenue neutrality relative to the prior year’s tax payments.
To make this even more attractive, you could let me “buy down” my marginal tax rate on new income by foregoing some deductions such as mortgage payments. So I would agree to pay 26%, say, on more of my income (I won’t deduct mortgage interest) if you lower the rate of taxation on new income I earn to, say, 24%.
This idea is very similar to health insurance plans that require us to choose at the beginning of the year what kind of plan we want, and how much money we want to put into a reimbursement account. Let’s extend that principle to taxation, remove some inefficiency, and make everyone better off.
Thursday, November 09, 2006
On Fisheries and Science in the Headlines
Last week, a group of scientists were very successful in getting their study on fisheries reported broadly throughout the world's media. See, for example, Collapse of All Wild Fisheries Predicted in 45 Years.
Anyone who knows me knows that I care a lot about the state of fisheries, both fresh and saltwater. I value fisheries for recreation and for food, as well as for their overall role in a healthy ecosystem.
But I cannot support the headline claim of this recent study. A story in the Seattle Times ,"Will seafood nets be empty? Grim outlook draws skeptics," tears it apart particularly well, showing first the graph that supposedly supports the prediction of complete collapse in 45 years. It looks like the authors were not content to simply project a trend forward, they actually projected a nonlinear trend forward -- a nonlinear trend with increasing negative slope!! Even worse, one of the authors accidentally included the Seattle Times in an email meant for someone else. Quoting from the ST article:
"In a note to colleagues that was mistakenly sent to The Seattle Times, Worm wrote that the projection could act as a "news hook to get people's attention."
"One reason why nobody cares about marine biodiversity is that there seemed no clear end in sight," he continued. "...
Well, it's time to wake up — IF the current trend continues we will see drastic consequences in our own lifetime."
I know how nice it is to get one's research results written up well in the national media. But doing bad science to get people's attention is really sad.
Anyone who knows me knows that I care a lot about the state of fisheries, both fresh and saltwater. I value fisheries for recreation and for food, as well as for their overall role in a healthy ecosystem.
But I cannot support the headline claim of this recent study. A story in the Seattle Times ,"Will seafood nets be empty? Grim outlook draws skeptics," tears it apart particularly well, showing first the graph that supposedly supports the prediction of complete collapse in 45 years. It looks like the authors were not content to simply project a trend forward, they actually projected a nonlinear trend forward -- a nonlinear trend with increasing negative slope!! Even worse, one of the authors accidentally included the Seattle Times in an email meant for someone else. Quoting from the ST article:
"In a note to colleagues that was mistakenly sent to The Seattle Times, Worm wrote that the projection could act as a "news hook to get people's attention."
"One reason why nobody cares about marine biodiversity is that there seemed no clear end in sight," he continued. "...
Well, it's time to wake up — IF the current trend continues we will see drastic consequences in our own lifetime."
I know how nice it is to get one's research results written up well in the national media. But doing bad science to get people's attention is really sad.
The Political Party We Need
It was getting a little hard to defend some parts of the Republican Party's agenda and actions, so I am not entirely heartbroken over the election. And the rest of the world should note how quickly and smoothly the US can change its political standing. The system does work. I think a strong case can even be made for Allen to not challenge the Virginia result. The chance of overturning it would seem to be low, while the benefits of taking the high road seem large.
What I long for is a political party that would be conservative on economics (especially spending and regulation), and on national defense, but liberal on many social issues, particularly those concerning individual rights and privacy. If the Democrats could claim that ground, they would get a lot of Republican support. Or, I could imagine a part of the Republican Party discarding some of the more religious, social conservatives for a more Libertarian leaning party. The problem there is that we would have three parties, with the two on the right sure to lose to the one on the left. Could a three party system be sustained in the US today? Maybe.
I worry that the Democrats will go too far to satisfy those furthest to the left on spending, regulation, and general "government is the answer to all questions" issues. If they resist that, relying more on Bill Clinton's views on the role of government in the economy, they could be a real powerhouse.
What I long for is a political party that would be conservative on economics (especially spending and regulation), and on national defense, but liberal on many social issues, particularly those concerning individual rights and privacy. If the Democrats could claim that ground, they would get a lot of Republican support. Or, I could imagine a part of the Republican Party discarding some of the more religious, social conservatives for a more Libertarian leaning party. The problem there is that we would have three parties, with the two on the right sure to lose to the one on the left. Could a three party system be sustained in the US today? Maybe.
I worry that the Democrats will go too far to satisfy those furthest to the left on spending, regulation, and general "government is the answer to all questions" issues. If they resist that, relying more on Bill Clinton's views on the role of government in the economy, they could be a real powerhouse.
Those Missing Bass Signs...
See my post immediately below on the lack of Bass signs around Hanover during the recent campaign. Now it seems that some of the Bass signs may have been stolen.
I was reading a story in the Valley News last night about someone in Enfield who had been arrested for taking Bass signs from alongside the road. The police followed the individual home and, when the perp failed to respond to their requests to appear at the front door, they knocked the door down! The poor fellow was arrested on two counts of possession of stolen property.
As I have had my own campaign signs stolen from my front yard, and my Bush sticker ripped off my truck's bumper, I was feeling pretty good about this story. But then I realized I knew the culprit! He is the son of a friend, and he used to babysit for my kids all the time! Ah, the follies of the youth. I hope they go a little easy on him. I don't think Bass lost because of a few signs being stolen.
I was reading a story in the Valley News last night about someone in Enfield who had been arrested for taking Bass signs from alongside the road. The police followed the individual home and, when the perp failed to respond to their requests to appear at the front door, they knocked the door down! The poor fellow was arrested on two counts of possession of stolen property.
As I have had my own campaign signs stolen from my front yard, and my Bush sticker ripped off my truck's bumper, I was feeling pretty good about this story. But then I realized I knew the culprit! He is the son of a friend, and he used to babysit for my kids all the time! Ah, the follies of the youth. I hope they go a little easy on him. I don't think Bass lost because of a few signs being stolen.
Monday, November 06, 2006
Bass vs. Hodes, US Representative for NH
So I have observed many electoral campaigns in the Upper Valley of NH, having lived here now for 23 years. Republicans have been an endangered species for a long time around here, and it is getting even more lonely of late. That said, I have never seen such a dearth of Republican campaign materials. No signs, no posters, no ads in the papers...Well, one sad little ad in the Valley News half-heartedly telling Republicans that their vote matters. Meanwhile, the Democrat Hodes has simply blanketed the landscape with campaign stuff. I can't drive anywhere without Hodes intruding on my thoughts.
If Charlie Bass loses his House seat, I will not be surprised. I understand better than anyone the idea of optimizing use of resources, but the incremental cost of doing a LITTLE SOMETHING even in a Democrat stronghold is so low that it has to be worthwhile. The complete lack of any effort around here makes me suspect that the Bass campaign is asleep at the wheel. Not a good indicator.
Well, I would be perfectly happy if the result tomorrow is Democratic control of the House and Republican control of the Senate. For a Libertarian, gridlock reads: Less new legislation.
Tomorrow should be interesting. Of course, given the last couple elections, we might not get final results for some time.
If Charlie Bass loses his House seat, I will not be surprised. I understand better than anyone the idea of optimizing use of resources, but the incremental cost of doing a LITTLE SOMETHING even in a Democrat stronghold is so low that it has to be worthwhile. The complete lack of any effort around here makes me suspect that the Bass campaign is asleep at the wheel. Not a good indicator.
Well, I would be perfectly happy if the result tomorrow is Democratic control of the House and Republican control of the Senate. For a Libertarian, gridlock reads: Less new legislation.
Tomorrow should be interesting. Of course, given the last couple elections, we might not get final results for some time.
Sunday, October 22, 2006
Private Equity and Venture Capital Firms Acting Anti-Competitively?
An interesting story last week suggested that the Justice Department was investigating private equity firms for possible anti-competitive behavior.
Just this last spring, a student of mine at Tuck did an independent study on the incentives and potential for cooperative behavior in the private equity and venture capital arenas. How's that for prescience?
Justice's focus appears to be on private equity firms and their behavior in auctions for companies (by the way, I have a paper with exactly that title: "Auctions of Companies", Economic Inquiry Vol 39 Issue 1 January 2001). Judging from the news reports, the investigation focuses on behavior by the firms that could reduce competition in the auctions and result in lower prices. This reminds me a bit of claims that the major audit firms were not aggressively competing against one another in bidding for audit jobs, since they realized that they were in a repeated game with the same players. Certainly there are good arguments from game theory to suggest that in a repeated context there are numerous strategies that evoke ongoing cooperative behavior and overcome any tendency to the classic "prisoners' dilemma." One strategy that has gotten a lot of play in theory is "tit for tat." In the private equity world, this would mean that if one firm were to bid aggressively for a company in one auction, then in the next auction a competitive private equity firm would bid aggressively just to punish the first firm. Of course, in the Middle East tit-for-tat seems to cause unrelenting cycles of escalating retaliation...
This is also nothing more than an interesting theoretical possibility without any convincing empirical evidence. And the story can be applied to almost every industrial setting where a relatively small number of firms compete with one another in a repeated context. So at this point it sounds like a Justice Dept. fishing trip.
My student and I were more interested in other areas where cooperation would pay. This story goes back to work by John Lott and myself: "Externalities and Corporate Objectives in a World with Diversified Shareholder/Consumers," Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, March 1996.
Suppose one venture capital firm has investments in two portfolio companies, which we will call A and B. What if A and B have some competitive fronts, or even more interesting, areas where there are complementarities? Then the venture capitalist should internalize those externalities and make sure that the two firms act so as to maximize their JOINT value rather than maximizing values independent of one another. If the two firms are interacting competitively, then joint value maximization could be contrary to consumer welfare, but if the two firms interact with complementarities, then joint value maximization would enhance consumer welfare.
Or to take it another step, suppose there are two venture capital firms, VC1 and VC2. And suppose that, through the syndication process, each venture capital firm has investments in both of the client firms A and B. Typically in these situations, one VC firm takes the lead investment role in each syndication. So VC1 might be the lead in Firm A and VC2 would be the lead in Firm B. On the surface, since the two VCs would have unequal stakes in the two clients, they would not each have incentives to maximize joint value of A and B. However, if VC1 runs Firm A as to maximize value of A at the loss of value to Firm B, VC2 will suffer. Similarly if VC2 runs B so as to destroy value at client Firm A, then VC1 will suffer. The two VCs might see that they would both be better off if they managed their clients with an eye to joint maximization. As with the private equity firms, any such coordination like this is much more likely to arise if VC1 and VC2 are in repeated syndications.
In 1953, the US government brought suit against 17 investment banking firms (US v. Morgan et al), alleging that they had used the syndication system as a means to perpetuate their coordination in investment banking. The case was lost, with the judge concluding that the defendants had acted independently and that the syndication system had an efficiency role to play.
My prediction is that history will repeat itself. Maybe this time we will be spared the cost of an extensive fishing trip. On the other hand, maybe the guys in Justice agree with me on something: A bad day fishing is better than a good day at work.
Just this last spring, a student of mine at Tuck did an independent study on the incentives and potential for cooperative behavior in the private equity and venture capital arenas. How's that for prescience?
Justice's focus appears to be on private equity firms and their behavior in auctions for companies (by the way, I have a paper with exactly that title: "Auctions of Companies", Economic Inquiry Vol 39 Issue 1 January 2001). Judging from the news reports, the investigation focuses on behavior by the firms that could reduce competition in the auctions and result in lower prices. This reminds me a bit of claims that the major audit firms were not aggressively competing against one another in bidding for audit jobs, since they realized that they were in a repeated game with the same players. Certainly there are good arguments from game theory to suggest that in a repeated context there are numerous strategies that evoke ongoing cooperative behavior and overcome any tendency to the classic "prisoners' dilemma." One strategy that has gotten a lot of play in theory is "tit for tat." In the private equity world, this would mean that if one firm were to bid aggressively for a company in one auction, then in the next auction a competitive private equity firm would bid aggressively just to punish the first firm. Of course, in the Middle East tit-for-tat seems to cause unrelenting cycles of escalating retaliation...
This is also nothing more than an interesting theoretical possibility without any convincing empirical evidence. And the story can be applied to almost every industrial setting where a relatively small number of firms compete with one another in a repeated context. So at this point it sounds like a Justice Dept. fishing trip.
My student and I were more interested in other areas where cooperation would pay. This story goes back to work by John Lott and myself: "Externalities and Corporate Objectives in a World with Diversified Shareholder/Consumers," Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, March 1996.
Suppose one venture capital firm has investments in two portfolio companies, which we will call A and B. What if A and B have some competitive fronts, or even more interesting, areas where there are complementarities? Then the venture capitalist should internalize those externalities and make sure that the two firms act so as to maximize their JOINT value rather than maximizing values independent of one another. If the two firms are interacting competitively, then joint value maximization could be contrary to consumer welfare, but if the two firms interact with complementarities, then joint value maximization would enhance consumer welfare.
Or to take it another step, suppose there are two venture capital firms, VC1 and VC2. And suppose that, through the syndication process, each venture capital firm has investments in both of the client firms A and B. Typically in these situations, one VC firm takes the lead investment role in each syndication. So VC1 might be the lead in Firm A and VC2 would be the lead in Firm B. On the surface, since the two VCs would have unequal stakes in the two clients, they would not each have incentives to maximize joint value of A and B. However, if VC1 runs Firm A as to maximize value of A at the loss of value to Firm B, VC2 will suffer. Similarly if VC2 runs B so as to destroy value at client Firm A, then VC1 will suffer. The two VCs might see that they would both be better off if they managed their clients with an eye to joint maximization. As with the private equity firms, any such coordination like this is much more likely to arise if VC1 and VC2 are in repeated syndications.
In 1953, the US government brought suit against 17 investment banking firms (US v. Morgan et al), alleging that they had used the syndication system as a means to perpetuate their coordination in investment banking. The case was lost, with the judge concluding that the defendants had acted independently and that the syndication system had an efficiency role to play.
My prediction is that history will repeat itself. Maybe this time we will be spared the cost of an extensive fishing trip. On the other hand, maybe the guys in Justice agree with me on something: A bad day fishing is better than a good day at work.
The Media Cascading into Falsehoods Once Again?
There are numerous reports in both newspapers and on the radio (I haven't had the TV on, but no doubt it is there too) of an American diplomat who supposedly said on Al Jazeera that the US has been "arrogant and stupid" in Iraq.
The only problem is that the diplomat was speaking in Arabic (good to hear that they can do that!) and Arabic can be tough to translate into English.
So do we think that every media outlet that passes this story on has had their own translator check the accuracy of the translation? Or is everyone just assuming that since someone ran the first story, and then someone else respectable ran the story, that it must be right?
In information cascades, you will frequently have everyone coming to the same wrong conclusion, even when their own private information suggests a different conclusion. The situation above could be a perfect example: a reporter who knows a little Arabic might check the actual words, but if they are not expert, then they will put more weight on the cascade of everyone else saying the original translation was right than on their own opinion. The result? A cascade of the same story, with the same translation.
The only problem is that the diplomat was speaking in Arabic (good to hear that they can do that!) and Arabic can be tough to translate into English.
So do we think that every media outlet that passes this story on has had their own translator check the accuracy of the translation? Or is everyone just assuming that since someone ran the first story, and then someone else respectable ran the story, that it must be right?
In information cascades, you will frequently have everyone coming to the same wrong conclusion, even when their own private information suggests a different conclusion. The situation above could be a perfect example: a reporter who knows a little Arabic might check the actual words, but if they are not expert, then they will put more weight on the cascade of everyone else saying the original translation was right than on their own opinion. The result? A cascade of the same story, with the same translation.
Friday, October 13, 2006
Record Breaking, and Deadly, Early Snow
An update: A state of emergency in the Buffalo area from the record early snowfall, and tragically, three deaths attributed to the snow. Health care workers had to bring dialysis patients in to the hospital and bring other medical supplies to people who could not get out.
Two Feet of Snow in October!
Ah, how I wish I were in Buffalo today, getting socked by lake effect snow. Brings me right back to home in the good old UP of Michigan. Soon we will be getting some snow in NH as well, but we don't get blizzards out here like we did in the UP. I still remember one snowstorm that stranded hundreds of cars along US 41 for at least a whole day.
By the way, if climate change reduces the severity and frequency of snowstorms like this in the large metropolitan areas of the Northeastern US, do the financial savings and reduced lives lost (how many people die from heart attacks every year shoveling snow?) count as a benefit?
By the way, if climate change reduces the severity and frequency of snowstorms like this in the large metropolitan areas of the Northeastern US, do the financial savings and reduced lives lost (how many people die from heart attacks every year shoveling snow?) count as a benefit?
An Admirable Peace Prize
The 2006 Nobel Peace Prize has been awarded to economist Muhammad Yunus and the pioneering microfinance organization, Grameen Bank. This is wonderful. Microfinance is a great institutional innovation that helps get capital, in small amounts, to entrepreneurs who can help eliminate poverty and provide goods and services in developing areas of the world. A good number of Tuck's MBA students are interested in microfinance. While it will be hard to get mainstream capital markets involved in any large way in microfinance, the point of developments like these is that they do not need to be huge to have a significant effect.
Wednesday, October 11, 2006
Two Papers for the Price of One
I was meeting with a very famous economist last week, lamenting the deterioration in coverage of business news by the Wall Street Journal. My guest said, yes, one of his friends laughs about getting two papers for the price of one with the WSJ: the traditionally conservative opinions on the editorial page, and now increasingly, a liberal slant towards the news in the rest of the paper.
This blog of mine started with my observations of poor reporting in the WSJ's front page story on the British Petroleum "corner" of the US propane market. I will now add another observation to the database, this time from the October 6 edition, an article on the front page entitled,"How Quiet Moves by a Publisher Sway Billions in Drug Spending." Ominously, this is noted as the fourth in a series titled "Health Care Goldmines. Middlemen Strike it Rich." Not off to a very good start with those leading words, are we now?
Since the WSJ online is a subscription service, and I don't have an account, I don't know of any way to link to the article. I apologize for that, but using the title and the author and date you could easily find it.
My apologies to the writer, Barbara Martinez, if I appear a little harsh here.
But this article is one of the more breathless juvenile attempts at creating (not exposing) a business scandal that I have ever seen. I really expect more from what was once the world's leading economics and business newspaper.
The thrust of the story and situation, as best I can fathom, is as follows: One company, First DataBank, has historically collected data on average wholesale prices for pharmaceuticals. These data were used in setting a benchmark that determined what retail pharmacies would be paid by insurers when the pharmacies dispensed drugs to individuals. From the sounds of it, the average wholesale price (AWP) would be used as a base, from which an insurer would tack on a margin to compensate the pharmacy. The higher the AWP, the higher the compensation for the pharmacy,
That is all well and good. The main claim, from a court case in Boston, is that First DataBank was collecting shoddy data -- that in the past several years, only one firm was being surveyed, the drug wholesaler McKesson. A second claim seems to be that First DataBank raised its reported average wholesale price around 2002 -- and since there was not really a valid survey being conducted at the time, any such raise of the reported AWP would be unjustified. The article, by innuendo, attempts to rope McKesson into this business. McKesson would not appear to benefit directly from any increase in the AWP. Its customers, the pharmacies, conceivably could benefit from an increase in AWP that was not actually caused by a real increase in wholesale prices, for the pharmacies would get more compensation but would not be paying more at the wholesale level. I suppose you could say that McKesson would benefit indirectly, if its customers were to benefit. There are no claims anywhere in the article that First DataBank and McKesson were colluding actively to raise AWP. There are some emails reported in the article, including one from some unnamed McKesson manager, saying "that is awesome" about how pharmacies would get higher compensation.
So there are several things that really bug me about this story. The naivete is striking. Here is one example: "Between the manufacturer and the end user stand a variety of middlemen who take their cuts." Standing alone, that may not be too bad. In the context of the article, it shows a view of middlemen as parasites that should be driven out of any college freshman's mind by their introductory economics course. Another example of naivete is a paragraph that attempts to show how pharmacies have been profiting in the last few years. The paragraph mixes stock returns with Walgreen's doubling of net income and ends with "Share prices of the three major PBMs (pharmacy benefit managers) are also sharply up over the past few years." I love to get reports written by students like that; they are so much fun to tear apart. "Sharply up?" Is that some scientific term, "sharply up?" Are they up relative to a relevant index? Up relative to zero?
Another major point of mine is that I think the reporter simply has the whole story wrong. I find it very difficult to believe that contracts of any significance were as reliant on the AWP as the article asserts. It is just very hard to believe that billions of dollars of reimbursement are based on such poor data. The article mentions that AWPs are not taken seriously in the industry, with some referring to AWP as "ain't what's paid." So the data are a joke, but billions of dollars ride on it. If this is true, then THAT is the story! Why would insurers be using such a terrible metric for their reimbursement schemes, a metric that is not only inaccurate but subject to manipulation because only one company is being sampled. Rather than a story on middlemen making profits, we should have a story on stupidity in the insurance and reimbursement industry.
A third point is the needless and slanted language throughout the whole story. I have already pointed out the headline and the title of the series. Here are just a few more juicy quotes:
"For years, a little known unit...played a powerful role...
"The new prices had the effect of fattening the profits...
" Now a tentative legal settlement, reached quietly in a Boston court...
"Even as patients face higher co-payments...many pharmacies and PBMs are prospering...
"Documents ... suggest that McKesson had a key part...
Wow. I am just breathless from the excitement of reading this. A little known unit, playing a powerful role, fattening profits, a quiet settlement, companies prospering while patients pay more, a wholesaler playing a key part...
When is the movie coming out? Will it star Meryl Streep?
Come on, Wall street Journal. I expect bias and slanting on the editorial page, and I love it. But nobody can complain because it is known to be opinion. But to have this kind of reporting on the front page? I expect better.
This blog of mine started with my observations of poor reporting in the WSJ's front page story on the British Petroleum "corner" of the US propane market. I will now add another observation to the database, this time from the October 6 edition, an article on the front page entitled,"How Quiet Moves by a Publisher Sway Billions in Drug Spending." Ominously, this is noted as the fourth in a series titled "Health Care Goldmines. Middlemen Strike it Rich." Not off to a very good start with those leading words, are we now?
Since the WSJ online is a subscription service, and I don't have an account, I don't know of any way to link to the article. I apologize for that, but using the title and the author and date you could easily find it.
My apologies to the writer, Barbara Martinez, if I appear a little harsh here.
But this article is one of the more breathless juvenile attempts at creating (not exposing) a business scandal that I have ever seen. I really expect more from what was once the world's leading economics and business newspaper.
The thrust of the story and situation, as best I can fathom, is as follows: One company, First DataBank, has historically collected data on average wholesale prices for pharmaceuticals. These data were used in setting a benchmark that determined what retail pharmacies would be paid by insurers when the pharmacies dispensed drugs to individuals. From the sounds of it, the average wholesale price (AWP) would be used as a base, from which an insurer would tack on a margin to compensate the pharmacy. The higher the AWP, the higher the compensation for the pharmacy,
That is all well and good. The main claim, from a court case in Boston, is that First DataBank was collecting shoddy data -- that in the past several years, only one firm was being surveyed, the drug wholesaler McKesson. A second claim seems to be that First DataBank raised its reported average wholesale price around 2002 -- and since there was not really a valid survey being conducted at the time, any such raise of the reported AWP would be unjustified. The article, by innuendo, attempts to rope McKesson into this business. McKesson would not appear to benefit directly from any increase in the AWP. Its customers, the pharmacies, conceivably could benefit from an increase in AWP that was not actually caused by a real increase in wholesale prices, for the pharmacies would get more compensation but would not be paying more at the wholesale level. I suppose you could say that McKesson would benefit indirectly, if its customers were to benefit. There are no claims anywhere in the article that First DataBank and McKesson were colluding actively to raise AWP. There are some emails reported in the article, including one from some unnamed McKesson manager, saying "that is awesome" about how pharmacies would get higher compensation.
So there are several things that really bug me about this story. The naivete is striking. Here is one example: "Between the manufacturer and the end user stand a variety of middlemen who take their cuts." Standing alone, that may not be too bad. In the context of the article, it shows a view of middlemen as parasites that should be driven out of any college freshman's mind by their introductory economics course. Another example of naivete is a paragraph that attempts to show how pharmacies have been profiting in the last few years. The paragraph mixes stock returns with Walgreen's doubling of net income and ends with "Share prices of the three major PBMs (pharmacy benefit managers) are also sharply up over the past few years." I love to get reports written by students like that; they are so much fun to tear apart. "Sharply up?" Is that some scientific term, "sharply up?" Are they up relative to a relevant index? Up relative to zero?
Another major point of mine is that I think the reporter simply has the whole story wrong. I find it very difficult to believe that contracts of any significance were as reliant on the AWP as the article asserts. It is just very hard to believe that billions of dollars of reimbursement are based on such poor data. The article mentions that AWPs are not taken seriously in the industry, with some referring to AWP as "ain't what's paid." So the data are a joke, but billions of dollars ride on it. If this is true, then THAT is the story! Why would insurers be using such a terrible metric for their reimbursement schemes, a metric that is not only inaccurate but subject to manipulation because only one company is being sampled. Rather than a story on middlemen making profits, we should have a story on stupidity in the insurance and reimbursement industry.
A third point is the needless and slanted language throughout the whole story. I have already pointed out the headline and the title of the series. Here are just a few more juicy quotes:
"For years, a little known unit...played a powerful role...
"The new prices had the effect of fattening the profits...
" Now a tentative legal settlement, reached quietly in a Boston court...
"Even as patients face higher co-payments...many pharmacies and PBMs are prospering...
"Documents ... suggest that McKesson had a key part...
Wow. I am just breathless from the excitement of reading this. A little known unit, playing a powerful role, fattening profits, a quiet settlement, companies prospering while patients pay more, a wholesaler playing a key part...
When is the movie coming out? Will it star Meryl Streep?
Come on, Wall street Journal. I expect bias and slanting on the editorial page, and I love it. But nobody can complain because it is known to be opinion. But to have this kind of reporting on the front page? I expect better.
Tuesday, October 03, 2006
Raising High before Smiting Down
Last night at Tuck, yours truly was on a panel discussing climate change. It was fun, and we had Professors Richard Howarth and Walter Sinott-Armstrong from "up the street" here as well.
I detect a certain cockiness in some of the climate change scientist crowd, and it infects even the more casual observers of the science. A telltale remark is along the lines of, "Well, 1000 scientists believe it to be right, so how can we argue?" (Now what exactly "it" is that is right is of course very interesting. I said numerous times that I believe some climate change has occurred and that humans are likely responsible for some of it, but people still asked me after what it would take to make me believe...)
So if a 1000 scientists believe a paradigm or theory to be absolutely true, that is the end of the story right?
Just in my short academic career, I can think of three paradigms in economics that have been overturned quite dramatically. At least two of them were characterized before the fall of extreme confidence in the paradigm -- yes, cockiness.
Two examples come from finance. The Capital Asset Pricing Model in the 70s and early 80s was held to be the key to understanding asset pricing, in particular the cross section of stock market returns. It is now dead.
A second related one comes from finance as well -- versions of market efficiency, especially that rational investors determine prices and that any inefficiencies in prices would be quickly eliminated. Now I and others can still argue this one pretty well, but there is no doubt that two decades of empirical studies on stock market pricing anomalies, along with experimental work on behavioral economics and finance, has removed the aura of invincibility around strong forms of market efficiency.
A third one is outside of my area a bit, but a colleague suggested it this morning: the death of structural equation macroeconomic modeling upon the development of the rational expectations critique by Robert Lucas. The Lucas critique effectively brought a whole industry of macro modeling to a stop.
So let's be a little respectful of the scientific process. The beauty of these examples is that knowledge does evolve: that even in a discipline as self-sure as the finance profession, a steady stream of contrary theory and evidence, even when produced by a small set of contrarians (think Richard Thaler of behavior finance), can lead to upheavals in the fundamental structure of theory.
I detect a certain cockiness in some of the climate change scientist crowd, and it infects even the more casual observers of the science. A telltale remark is along the lines of, "Well, 1000 scientists believe it to be right, so how can we argue?" (Now what exactly "it" is that is right is of course very interesting. I said numerous times that I believe some climate change has occurred and that humans are likely responsible for some of it, but people still asked me after what it would take to make me believe...)
So if a 1000 scientists believe a paradigm or theory to be absolutely true, that is the end of the story right?
Just in my short academic career, I can think of three paradigms in economics that have been overturned quite dramatically. At least two of them were characterized before the fall of extreme confidence in the paradigm -- yes, cockiness.
Two examples come from finance. The Capital Asset Pricing Model in the 70s and early 80s was held to be the key to understanding asset pricing, in particular the cross section of stock market returns. It is now dead.
A second related one comes from finance as well -- versions of market efficiency, especially that rational investors determine prices and that any inefficiencies in prices would be quickly eliminated. Now I and others can still argue this one pretty well, but there is no doubt that two decades of empirical studies on stock market pricing anomalies, along with experimental work on behavioral economics and finance, has removed the aura of invincibility around strong forms of market efficiency.
A third one is outside of my area a bit, but a colleague suggested it this morning: the death of structural equation macroeconomic modeling upon the development of the rational expectations critique by Robert Lucas. The Lucas critique effectively brought a whole industry of macro modeling to a stop.
So let's be a little respectful of the scientific process. The beauty of these examples is that knowledge does evolve: that even in a discipline as self-sure as the finance profession, a steady stream of contrary theory and evidence, even when produced by a small set of contrarians (think Richard Thaler of behavior finance), can lead to upheavals in the fundamental structure of theory.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)